Trols from Ethiopia, Abebe and collaborators 
also observed a difference in apoptotic gene expression in the different 
clinical cohorts. This study suggested that monocytes from the Ethiopian TB patients were less sensitive to TNF-a-dependent Epigenetic Reader Domain apoptosis 22948146 than the other cell lineages (notably T-cells), due to shedding of the TNFR2 receptor by monocytes [26]. These findings are consistent with the data reported here, and moreover provide a mechanism to explain these results. The inhibition of TNF-a dependent apoptosis of infected macrophage has been suggested as a mechanism used by Mtb to Autophagy preserve its intracellular niche and escape the host immune response [21] and it has been observed that virulent Mtb strains are able to directly inhibit TNF-a-dependent apoptosis of macrophages by activating the release of membrane-bound TNFR2 as the soluble form by infected host cells [13]. Similarly, observations from Mtb-induced apoptosis models suggested that FLIPs degradation was associated with TNF-induced apoptosis of Mtb infected macrophages. [15]. The higher level of FLIPs in Mtb-infected individuals in this study is concordant with the different in vitro observations and suggests that Mtb-induced increase of FLIPs may reflect an attempt by the pathogen to protect macrophages ?the pathogen’s preferred host cell ?from TNF-a-dependent apoptosis. Whether this leads to latent infection or TB disease appears to correlate with the relative preservation or loss, respectively of lymphocytes in the peripheral blood of infected individuals, with a loss of T cell numbers correlating with the development of TB, aspreviously suggested [30,31]. While most of these 10457188 other studies were performed in vitro or in active TB patients, the current observations from the Malagasy cohort suggests that this mechanism is also active in infected household contacts and that early signs of monocyte/lymphocyte imbalance may identify those individuals who are failing to contain the infection. Also supportive of our results, a recent microarray study on human TB has shown a significant decrease of lymphocytic cells and an increase of myeloid lineage transcripts in active TB patients, which was attributed to an expansion of inflammatory monocytes (CD14+CD16+) [31]. Further longitudinal studies to characterise monocytic subpopulations in TB contacts are therefore potentially very interesting. The mechanism involved in the relative decrease in lymphocytes is as yet unclear. Observations from other studies in TB patients suggested a significant decrease in the number of certain Mtb-reactive T cells and a decreased production of IFN-c was linked with activation of some apoptotic pathways [22,23]. A Gambian study also found that a relative decrease in CD4 T cells in TB contacts was correlated with risk of subsequent TB, though the mechanism was not indicated [30]. The hypothesis that imbalances in regulation of apoptosis may lead to a loss of immune function and subsequent progress to TB is therefore an attractive one; however more work is required before we can say anything definitive about cause and effect. These results do however, highlight the importance of a better understanding of the role of apoptosis in the development of TB.ConclusionsIn this study, we evaluated the utility of both gene expression and cell proportions, as combined markers for characterizing the protective response against TB in humans. Changes in the expression of TNF-associated apoptotic genes seemed to be as.Trols from Ethiopia, Abebe and collaborators also observed a difference in apoptotic gene expression in the different clinical cohorts. This study suggested that monocytes from the Ethiopian TB patients were less sensitive to TNF-a-dependent apoptosis 22948146 than the other cell lineages (notably T-cells), due to shedding of the TNFR2 receptor by monocytes [26]. These findings are consistent with the data reported here, and moreover provide a mechanism to explain these results. The inhibition of TNF-a dependent apoptosis of infected macrophage has been suggested as a mechanism used by Mtb to preserve its intracellular niche and escape the host immune response [21] and it has been observed that virulent Mtb strains are able to directly inhibit TNF-a-dependent apoptosis of macrophages by activating the release of membrane-bound TNFR2 as the soluble form by infected host cells [13]. Similarly, observations from Mtb-induced apoptosis models suggested that FLIPs degradation was associated with TNF-induced apoptosis of Mtb infected macrophages. [15]. The higher level of FLIPs in Mtb-infected individuals in this study is concordant with the different in vitro observations and suggests that Mtb-induced increase of FLIPs may reflect an attempt by the pathogen to protect macrophages ?the pathogen’s preferred host cell ?from TNF-a-dependent apoptosis. Whether this leads to latent infection or TB disease appears to correlate with the relative preservation or loss, respectively of lymphocytes in the peripheral blood of infected individuals, with a loss of T cell numbers correlating with the development of TB, aspreviously suggested [30,31]. While most of these 10457188 other studies were performed in vitro or in active TB patients, the current observations from the Malagasy cohort suggests that this mechanism is also active in infected household contacts and that early signs of monocyte/lymphocyte imbalance may identify those individuals who are failing to contain the infection. Also supportive of our results, a recent microarray study on human TB has shown a significant decrease of lymphocytic cells and an increase of myeloid lineage transcripts in active TB patients, which was attributed to an expansion of inflammatory monocytes (CD14+CD16+) [31]. Further longitudinal studies to characterise monocytic subpopulations in TB contacts are therefore potentially very interesting. The mechanism involved in the relative decrease in lymphocytes is as yet unclear. Observations from other studies in TB patients suggested a significant decrease in the number of certain Mtb-reactive T cells and a decreased production of IFN-c was linked with activation of some apoptotic pathways [22,23]. A Gambian study also found that a relative decrease in CD4 T cells in TB contacts was correlated with risk of subsequent TB, though the mechanism was not indicated [30]. The hypothesis that imbalances in regulation of apoptosis may lead to a loss of immune function and subsequent progress to TB is therefore an attractive one; however more work is required before we can say anything definitive about cause and effect. These results do however, highlight the importance of a better understanding of the role of apoptosis in the development of TB.ConclusionsIn this study, we evaluated the utility of both gene expression and cell proportions, as combined markers for characterizing the protective response against TB in humans. Changes in the expression of TNF-associated apoptotic genes seemed to be as.
